Movie polls never tend to work for me. I’m rubbish at making my own (I love too many and too wide a variety I think) and those that get put together by ‘experts’ seem too ‘poncey’ (yup, I said it) and over look the films I love and enjoy. So, when Empire compiled it’s list of the 500 greatest movies ever (voted for by readers, critics and some mysterious movie people) I immediately approached with a sense of cynicism and, having now assessed it, I think quite rightfully.
Admittedly, readers of a movie magazine are a good place to assess public opinion on the best films out there, but it’s a pretty specific group of people. And, how exactly do you judge what makes the greatest movie ever in the history of the world? I wrote about this a little while ago – how can we all agree what makes a film great? Judging a badly made movie can be agreeable – bad acting, bad script, rubbish camera work etc etc. However, I could quite happily admit to High School Musical having all those things, but I’ll still sit and watch it because I enjoy it.
And so, judging film by ‘quality’ vs ‘entertainment and enjoyment’ (which is essentially what film is… taking away all theory and analysis) immediately makes for opposite opinions.
It is no suprise that Godfather is no.1 on the list. I know this film is a good film – but, do I enjoy it? No. Nor do I enjoy Goodfellas (no.6), any Tarantino films (no.9, 97, 325 and 423) or horror movies (i.e. Sixth Sense no.332 or Dawn of the Dead no.415).
Considering this is about the top movies of ALL TIME, is it right that out of 500 movies, 85 of them were released in the past 8 years?
5 were made this year
- Dark Knight (no.15)
- Wall-E (no.373)
- Cloverfield (no.394)
- Iron Man (no.408)
- Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull (no.453)
15 were made last year, and this includes:
- Hot Fuzz (no.374)
- Transformers (no.309)
- The Bourne Ultimatum (no.234)
- Superbad (no.487)
- Juno (no.463)
and then -
- 11 were released in 2006
- 11 in 2005
- 17 in 2004 (who knew 2004 was so good for movies!?!)
- 8 in 2003
- and 9 in both 2002 and 2001.
These movies are fresh in the mind of the people voting, and are also more likely to have been seen by those voting, rather than perhaps more obscure older movies. This poll doesn’t represent ‘the greatest movies’ but instead may be a good reflection on what are the most watched movies. Yeah, Dark Knight was good – but is it seriously the 15th best movie ever made?
Coming up – movies that shouldn’t be there/so high up.
Tune in tomorrow